Portrait of G. E. Moore

G. E. Moore

1873–1958 · English philosopher

“"Good" can't be defined — you just know it”

Life and education

Born
4 November 1873, London, England
Died
24 October 1958, Cambridge
Education
Trinity College, Cambridge
Positions
Professor of Philosophy, Cambridge (1925–1939); editor of Mind (1921–1947)

English philosopher who, with Bertrand Russell, rebelled against British idealism and kicked off analytic philosophy. He made clear analysis of common sense and ordinary language the method of philosophy.

In Principia Ethica (1903) he argued that "good" can't be defined as a natural property like pleasure, calling that mistake the "naturalistic fallacy." The book became the starting point of 20th-century metaethics and influenced the Bloomsbury Group of Cambridge-connected intellectuals.

Timeline

  1. 1903"The Refutation of Idealism"; Principia Ethica
  2. 1921Editor of Mind
  3. 1925Professor at Cambridge; "A Defence of Common Sense"
  4. 1939"Proof of an External World" — "Here is one hand"

Big ideas

The naturalistic fallacyDefining "good" as a natural property like pleasure or desire is a mistake.
The open question argument"Is pleasure good?" is always a meaningful question. If good just meant pleasure, it wouldn't be.
Defending common senseCommonsense beliefs like "here is a hand" are more certain than any philosophical argument doubting them.

If you think like them…

If you're like Moore, you feel "good" is real but a different kind of thing from what science measures. You resist reducing moral judgments to feelings or taste, and you tend to pick the option with the better outcome. You also trust plain common sense over complicated theories.

Free willFree will is realFree will skeptic
Right actionConsequentialismDeontology
What morality isRealismAnti-realism
Mind & bodyPhysicalismDualism
Being youPsychologicalBodily

Rough positions on the five questions the quiz uses. These simplify each philosopher's actual views and are open to interpretation.

Thought experiments featuring them

Key works

Sources