Portrait of Robert Nozick

Robert Nozick

1938–2002 · American philosopher

“Individual rights are lines you can't cross”

Life and education

Born
16 November 1938, Brooklyn, New York, USA
Died
23 January 2002, Cambridge, Massachusetts
Education
Columbia (BA 1959); Princeton (PhD 1963)
Position
Harvard from 1969; University Professor

American philosopher whose Anarchy, State, and Utopia (1974) started from individual rights to defend a minimal state and made him libertarianism's leading theorist. The book is the most famous reply to his Harvard colleague John Rawls's A Theory of Justice.

He ranged far beyond political philosophy — epistemology, personal identity, rational choice, the meaning of life. His "experience machine" thought experiment, asking whether you'd plug into a machine that only gives you pleasure, is a classic objection to hedonism, and on personal identity he proposed the "closest continuer theory."

Timeline

  1. 1963PhD, Princeton
  2. 1969Full professor at Harvard at 30
  3. 1974Anarchy, State, and Utopia (National Book Award, 1975)
  4. 1981Philosophical Explanations — closest continuer theory, tracking theory of knowledge
  5. 1989The Examined Life
  6. 2001Invariances

Big ideas

Rights as side constraintsIndividual rights aren't goals to maximize but boundaries you can't cross. You can't sacrifice individuals even for a greater good.
The minimal state and entitlement theoryHoldings justly acquired and transferred are just. Anything beyond a minimal state protecting against force, theft and fraud violates rights.
The experience machineWould you plug into a machine that gives you any experience you want, for life? If not, you want more than pleasure.

If you think like them…

If you're like Nozick, you believe one person's rights come before the majority's interests. You instinctively push back on math that sacrifices individuals for the whole, and you value everyone being in charge of their own life. You also tend to believe your choices are genuinely yours.

Free willFree will is realFree will skeptic
Right actionConsequentialismDeontology
What morality isRealismAnti-realism
Mind & bodyPhysicalismDualism
Being youPsychologicalBodily

Rough positions on the five questions the quiz uses. These simplify each philosopher's actual views and are open to interpretation.

Thought experiments featuring them

Key works

Sources