Portrait of William James

William James

1842–1910 · American philosopher and psychologist

“My first act of free will is to believe in free will”

Life and education

Born
11 January 1842, New York City, USA
Died
26 August 1910, Chocorua, New Hampshire
Education
Harvard, MD (1869)
Position
Harvard (1872–1907), professor of physiology, psychology and philosophy

American philosopher and psychologist who, with Peirce and Dewey, defined pragmatism. He was the older brother of novelist Henry James. After studying medicine and teaching physiology at Harvard, he moved into psychology and philosophy and set up one of America's first psychology labs.

As a young man he went through a deep depression; he's said to have pulled through after writing in his 1870 diary that "my first act of free will shall be to believe in free will." His Principles of Psychology popularized the phrase "stream of consciousness."

Timeline

  1. 1869MD, Harvard
  2. 1884Lecture "The Dilemma of Determinism"
  3. 1890The Principles of Psychology
  4. 1897The Will to Believe
  5. 1902The Varieties of Religious Experience
  6. 1907Pragmatism

Big ideas

PragmatismThe meaning and truth of an idea show up in the difference it makes to our experience and lives.
The will to believeWhen evidence can't decide and the choice matters for life, you have the right to choose what to believe.
IndeterminismThe world has genuinely open possibilities. Regret only makes sense if something else could have happened.

If you think like them…

If you're like William James, you ask what difference an idea makes in real life before you care about grand theories. You approach questions like free will less through proof and more through "what kind of life does believing this create?" You feel that body, mind and the stream of memory all make up "you."

Free willFree will is realFree will skeptic
Right actionConsequentialismDeontology
What morality isRealismAnti-realism
Mind & bodyPhysicalismDualism
Being youPsychologicalBodily

Rough positions on the five questions the quiz uses. These simplify each philosopher's actual views and are open to interpretation.

Thought experiments featuring them

Key works

Sources